Exam 5: Free Will
James thinks that determinism involves a less rational conception of things than does indeterminism.
True
Do you think that actions can be intelligible but not deterministically caused? Explain.
Yes, it is possible for actions to be intelligible but not deterministically caused. Intelligible actions are those that can be understood or explained, while deterministically caused actions are those that are the result of specific causes and conditions.
For example, a person may make a decision based on their values, beliefs, and desires, which can be understood and explained, but the specific outcome of their decision may not be determined by any specific cause. This could be due to the presence of randomness, uncertainty, or free will in the decision-making process.
Furthermore, in the realm of quantum mechanics, there is evidence to suggest that certain events at the subatomic level are not deterministically caused, but can still be intelligible within the framework of probabilistic explanations.
In summary, while actions can be intelligible in that they can be understood or explained, they may not always be deterministically caused, leaving room for the possibility of indeterminism, free will, or randomness in human behavior and the natural world.
According to philosophical tradition, no choice is free unless it is
On Stace's view, the problem of free will is more apparent than real.
According to one view Nagel discusses, an action can be free and causally determined if
Why does Hume think that, properly understood, the doctrines of necessity and liberty are compatible? Do you agree?
Churchland insists that her neurobiological approach to human behavior is no threat to our self-esteem or sense of self-worth. Do you agree? Why or why not?
When applied to voluntary actions, Hume understands liberty to mean
Hume thinks that the dispute regarding free will shows that we are profoundly knowledgeable about the relation of cause and effect.
Churchland suggests that the traditional understanding of free will needs to be
Do you agree with James that chance is not as bad as the determinist takes it to be? Explain.
The agent in a Frankfurt-style case gains capacities because of the context.
How does Stace define "free will"? Do you agree with his definition? Explain.
According to Churchland, a __________ is a freely chosen action.
According to Churchland, we must hold people responsible for their actions because
Filters
- Essay(0)
- Multiple Choice(0)
- Short Answer(0)
- True False(0)
- Matching(0)